Motivation in Educational Contexts: Does Gender Matter?

Chapter One – Motivation in Educational Contexts: Does Gender Matter?

• Ruth Butler^,

• School of Education, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Mt. Scopus, Jerusalem, Israel

Available online 22 August 2014

 Show more 

doi:10.1016/bs.acdb.2014.05.001

Get rights and content

---

Abstract

Girls and women now outperform boys and men on many indices of academic achievement. Gender differences in motivation may underlie these trends. In this chapter, I review and integrate research on gender differences in self-evaluation, self-regulation, and achievement goals. I argue for the existence of gendered tendencies “to prove” versus “to try and to improve,” whereby males tend to orient to demonstrating and defending their abilities, and females to working hard and addressing deficiencies. I discuss how these motivations develop within social and educational contexts of learning, and intersect with gendered patterns of socialization, values, and behaviors in other arenas, especially relational ones. Recurring themes include the costs and benefits of differential emphases on competition and self-promotion versus affiliation and consideration of others in the family, peer group, and classroom. I conclude with some recommendations for creating classroom environments that might promote optimal motivation among all students, regardless of gender.

Keywords

• Gender differences;
• Achievement motivation;
• Self-evaluation;
• Social motives;
• Gender socialization